Experiences from more than 20 years in the TV news industry.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Word Police Strike Again - Kent Ninomiya

Kent Ninomiya - We are in the midst of an era of hypersensitivity over slips of the tongue and cultural issues. First there was the suspension of Kelly Tilghman for joking that Tiger Woods should be "lynched." Then it was ESPN's Dana Jacobson suspended for comments about Notre Dame and Jesus at a roast. Now it's CNN's Kyra Phillips coming under fire.

She was in a discussion with Gerri Willis and co-anchor. Willis joked that if she could predict the stock market, she and Phillips could run off to an island, prompting Phillips' , to ask not to be left out of the girls' getaway. This resulted in the following exchange:Gerri: Alright Don, you come too.Kyra: We could bring him along with the girls. Gerri: Come on!Kyra: He's paying! Thanks, Gerri.Don: A little sandwich!Kyra: Ooh!Gerri: Whoa, I have to go now!Kyra: Yeah, good time. You don't want to talk about the reverse oreo!

If you watch this exchange (you can find it easily on the internet) you will see that it's innocent banter. No one there was offended. However the hypersensitive among us could make this out to be racial insensitivity, sexual insensitivity or both. I would not be surprised if there are calls for suspensions. That seems to be in vogue these days.

I argue that cultural sensitivity is not the same as racial blindness. Pretending that we don't see that people are different is hypacritical. We should acknowledge and embrace these differences as what makes our American culture great. When someone makes a comment that is warmly greeted by the people they are addressing, it is not up to third parties to be gravely insulted. I believe that to be the case here with CNN. It's a bit different in the Jacobson and Tilghman cases since their comments were not so innocent, but I still think people over reacted. We have better things to do than micro manage every word people on TV say. Kent Ninomiya

0 comments: